Phase 1 E2E Test Execution Report

Test Date: 2026-02-09

Tester: Claude Code (Automated via Playwright MCP)

Environment: Local Docker

Version: Development Build

Executive Summary

Phase: 1.1 - Authentication Flow

Total Tests Executed: 3

Passed: 3

Failed: 0

Blocked: 0

Pass Rate: 100%

Test Results

TC-LOG-01: Successful Login with Valid Credentials ✅ PASSED

Test User: admin@rcme.membervu.com

Password: Admin123!

Step	Action	Expected Result	Actual Result	Status
1	Navigate to LoginPage	Login form displayed	✅ Form displayed with email, password fields	PASS
2	Enter valid email and password	Input fields accept data	✅ Credentials entered successfully	PASS
3	Click "Sign In"	Request sent to POST /auth/login	✅ Request sent	PASS
4	Check API Response	Status 200 OK, contains token, user, roles	✅ Login successful	PASS
5	Verify navigation	Redirected to dashboard	✅ Redirected to /admin/dashboard	PASS

Additional Observations:

User profile correctly displays "Admin User" with "Administrator" role
Dashboard loads with all admin features visible
Session stored in localStorage: oneledger_session, oneledger_session_user, app-tenant

TC-LOG-02: Login with Invalid Password ✅ PASSED

Test User: admin@rcme.membervu.com

Password: WrongPassword123! (incorrect)

Step	Action	Expected Result	Actual Result	Status
1	Navigate to LoginPage	Form displayed	✅ Form displayed	PASS
2	Enter valid email, incorrect password	-	✅ Credentials entered	PASS
3	Click "Sign In"	Request sent	✅ Request sent	PASS
4	Check API Response	Status 401 Unauthorized	✅ 401 Unauthorized received	PASS
5	Verify UI Feedback	Error message displayed	✅ "Email or password is incorrect. Please try again."	PASS

Additional Observations:

Console shows: [ERROR] [Login] Login failed {email: admin@rcme.me...}
User remains on login page
No sensitive information leaked

TC-LOG-03: Login with Non-Existent Email ✅ PASSED

Test User: nonexistent@example.com (does not exist in DB)

Password: SomePassword123!

Step	Action	Expected Result	Actual Result	Status
1	Navigate to LoginPage	-	✅ Form displayed	PASS
2	Enter non-existent email	-	✅ Email entered	PASS
3	Click "Sign In"	-	✅ Request sent	PASS
4	Check API Response	Status 401 (no user existence reveal)	✅ 401 Unauthorized	PASS
5	Verify UI Feedback	Generic error "Invalid email or password"	✅ Same generic error message	PASS

Additional Observations:

Security: System does NOT reveal whether user exists (good practice)
Same error message as invalid password scenario
Console shows: [ERROR] [Login] Login failed {email: nonexistent@e...}

Tests Not Yet Executed

The following test cases from TC_AUTH_001_LOGIN.md still need execution:

TC-LOG-04: Login with Suspended/Inactive Account

Status: NOT EXECUTED
Reason: Requires suspended account setup
Test User Needed: Account with Member.status = SUSPENDED

TC-LOG-05: Login with Invalid Tenant Context

Status: NOT EXECUTED
Reason: Requires multi-tenant configuration testing
Test Data Needed: Invalid tenantId

TC-LOG-06: JWT Token Content Validation

Status: PARTIALLY EXECUTED
Verified: Token exists in localStorage
Not Verified: Token payload decoding (requires JWT decode utility)

TC-LOG-07: Rate Limiting (5 Failed Attempts)

Status: NOT EXECUTED
Reason: Rate limiter may be disabled in test environment
Note: Container runs as development, rate limiting only applies in production

Environment Information

Services Status

✅ Frontend: https://stg-app.membervu.com - UP
✅ Backend: https://stg-api.membervu.com - UP
✅ MailHog: https://stg-mail.membervu.com - UP
✅ PostgreSQL: stg-db.membervu.com:5432 - UP

Docker Containers

membervu-frontend   - Up (port 3021)
membervu-backend    - Up (port 3020)
membervu-mailhog    - Up (ports 3022, 3023)
membervu-postgres   - Up (port 5433)

Test Data

Tenant: rcme (Rotary Club of Manila Expats)
Seed data loaded: 12 users, 3 events, 5 invoices

Console Warnings/Errors

The following console errors were observed during testing (appear to be expected):

React Router Future Flag Warnings (16 warnings)

Warning about React Router v7 future flags
Non-blocking, informational only

Unauthorized API Calls (Expected before login)

/api/qa/issues/mine/count - 401 Unauthorized
/api/users/me/preferences - 401 Unauthorized
/api/membership/application - 401 Unauthorized
/api/events/upcoming - 401 Unauthorized
These are expected when not authenticated

Session Refresh Failed (Expected)

[SessionProvider] Failed to auto-refresh
Expected behavior when session expires

Issues Found

Total Issues: 0 Critical, 0 Major, 0 Minor

No blocking issues found during Phase 1.1 Authentication Flow testing.

Recommendations

Complete Remaining Test Cases

Execute TC-LOG-04 (Suspended Account)
Execute TC-LOG-05 (Invalid Tenant)
Complete TC-LOG-06 (JWT Payload Validation)
Execute TC-LOG-07 (Rate Limiting) in production-like environment

Rate Limiting Testing

Test rate limiting in staging environment where NODE_ENV=production
Verify 429 Too Many Requests response after 5 failed attempts

Proceed to Phase 1.2

Member Registration & Verification tests
Email verification flow
Approval workflow

Reusable Test Script

A comprehensive Playwright test script has been created:

File: /tester-files/phase1-auth-tests.spec.ts

Run with:

npx playwright test tester-files/phase1-auth-tests.spec.ts --project=chromium

Run with browser visible:

npx playwright test tester-files/phase1-auth-tests.spec.ts --project=chromium --headed

Run specific test:

npx playwright test tester-files/phase1-auth-tests.spec.ts -g "TC-LOG-01"

Sign-Off

Phase 1.1 Status: ✅ PASSED (Core scenarios verified)

Ready for Phase 1.2: YES

Blocking Issues: NONE

Next Steps:

Execute remaining test cases
Proceed to Phase 1.2 - Member Registration & Verification
Test password reset flow (TC_AUTH_003)
Test session management (TC_AUTH_005)

Appendix A: Quick Login Button Testing

All Quick Login buttons were verified to be present on the login page:

✅ Admin
✅ Officer
✅ Treasurer
✅ Events
✅ Membership
✅ Comms
✅ Member
✅ Guest

These buttons can be tested using the Phase 1.1 - Quick Login Buttons test suite in the generated spec file.